Surface Piercings vs. Microdermals: Weighing the Pros and Cons

Surface Piercings vs. Microdermals: Weighing the Pros and Cons

Body modification isn’t just about the final look—it’s also about the process, the healing, and the long-term commitment. For anyone considering adornments beyond traditional earlobe or nostril piercings, surface and microdermal piercings offer intriguing alternatives. Both styles create a unique “floating” jewelry effect on flatter areas of the body, but each has its own set of advantages and challenges. Let’s break down the pros and cons of these two popular piercing options to help you decide which might be the best fit for your aesthetic and lifestyle.

What Are Surface Piercings?

Definition:
Surface piercings are placed on relatively flat areas of the body—like the nape of the neck, lower back, hips, or chest—where the jewelry sits horizontally under the skin. Instead of going through tissue like a standard piercing, a surface bar (shaped somewhat like a staple) is inserted beneath the surface. Both ends of the jewelry exit the skin, creating two visible points.

Pros of Surface Piercings:

  1. Distinctive Aesthetics:
    Surface piercings create a sleek, linear look. They can be arranged in patterns or pairs for dramatic body art that’s different from common facial or ear piercings.

  2. Easier Removal:
    If you decide the piercing no longer suits your style, a professional can generally remove a surface bar with relative ease. Once removed, the skin usually heals shut over time, though scarring may occur.

  3. Less Invasive Procedure:
    While all piercings carry some risk, surface piercings typically involve creating a channel just below the skin’s surface. This procedure can be relatively quick and straightforward in the hands of an experienced piercer.

Cons of Surface Piercings:

  1. Higher Risk of Rejection and Migration:
    Because surface piercings sit close to the surface, the body may try to push the jewelry out over time. This can result in migration, crooked positioning, or complete rejection of the jewelry.

  2. Longer Healing Times:
    Surface piercings can take several months or more to fully heal. During that time, extra care is needed to prevent snagging, irritation from clothing, or introducing bacteria.

  3. Limited Placement Options:
    Not all body areas are suitable for surface bars. Movement-heavy areas or spots subject to friction (like belts, tight clothing, or bra straps) can complicate healing and increase discomfort.


What Are Microdermal Piercings?

Definition:
Also known as dermal anchors, microdermal piercings consist of a small, flat base (anchor) placed just below the skin’s surface. A decorative top (like a gemstone or flat disc) screws into the anchor and sits flush with the skin, creating a single visible “point” of jewelry rather than two.

Pros of Microdermal Piercings:

  1. Versatile Placement:
    Microdermals can be placed almost anywhere on the body with enough tissue to secure the anchor. From cheekbones and collarbones to wrists and even fingers, they offer incredible versatility.

  2. Lower Visibility of Hardware:
    Because only one end of the jewelry is visible, microdermals appear as if gems or studs are simply “floating” on the skin. This minimalist look can be very visually appealing.

  3. Reduced Movement and Snagging Risk (in Some Areas):
    Properly placed microdermals are often more stable than surface bars. They can move less during healing if positioned well, reducing the likelihood of irritation due to friction—assuming they’re not placed in high-impact zones.

Cons of Microdermal Piercings:

  1. More Complex Removal:
    Unlike surface piercings, microdermal jewelry is anchored beneath the skin. Removal involves a small incision or specialized tools. Attempting to remove it yourself can lead to scarring, infection, or damage to the tissue.

  2. Risk of Snagging if Poorly Placed:
    While stability can be a pro, microdermals can still catch on clothing, hair, or accessories if they’re in high-contact areas. A snag can be painful and may disrupt the anchor’s hold in the skin.

  3. Healing and Infection Risks:
    Although they can be stable, microdermals still require diligent aftercare. Improper cleaning, trauma, or low-quality jewelry materials can lead to irritation or infection. Healing times vary from person to person and can be several months.


How to Decide Between Surface and Microdermals

1. Consider Your Anatomy and Lifestyle:
Think about where you want the piercing and how often that area comes into contact with clothing, straps, or other irritants. If the area is prone to movement and pressure, a surface piercing might be at higher risk of rejection, while a carefully placed microdermal might fare better.

2. Assess Your Commitment to Aftercare:
Both options need meticulous aftercare, especially during the initial healing phase. Daily cleaning, avoiding unnecessary touching, and protecting the area from trauma are crucial. If you’re confident you can maintain a strict hygiene routine, either could be suitable.

3. Plan for the Long Term:
If you think you might want to remove the piercing in the future, remember that a surface piercing is generally easier to take out. Microdermals, while discreet and versatile, can be more complicated to remove and may leave a more noticeable mark.

4. Consult a Professional Piercer:
Every body is unique. An experienced piercer can evaluate your anatomy, discuss your aesthetic goals, and guide you toward the option that’s most likely to heal well and complement your personal style.

Surface and microdermal piercings both offer a bold departure from traditional piercing placements, giving you the chance to turn nearly any flat canvas on your body into eye-catching art. Surface piercings provide a linear look and simpler removal, while microdermals deliver a single “floating” gem effect with greater placement versatility. By considering healing times, lifestyle factors, and long-term commitment, you can make an informed decision that results in a beautiful, lasting addition to your personal style.